Often while debating someone over the atrocities that have been committed throughout history in the name of religion, a charge is made by the religious that atheism is just as deadly and they bring up examples such as Pol Pot and Stalin[1] as examples of atheist atrocities. At first glance this accusation seems to have some teeth. After all they did commit some of the greatest crimes against humanity ever seen, and they were atheists, and so this is probably enough to convince some of the simplest of thinkers among us that yes, of course, atheism can precipitate as much death and destruction as religious zealotry and they go right on believing it without thinking any more on the subject. Unfortunately the reality is not quite so simple, and in fact, upon careful consideration, we will see that this conclusion really couldn't be more wrong.
The reality is that atheism was nothing but a by product to these men. Their real passion was nationalism. They envisioned themselves as the gods of their countries, and just like the jealous god of the Muslims and the Christians, they too wanted no god above them, and just like the Christian and Muslim gods they were atheists by their very nature. Religion is nothing more than the blind obedience to dogma. Is Nationalism anything more, or communism or Capitalism. They were simply taking advantage of the groundwork that had been laid by religion in the previous couple millenia. The human psyche was primed to follow without question, to submit to authority, to follow dogma without question. In short these regimes were nothing less than religions in their own right.
If you asked a bunch of atheists what the most important human quality is, I have little doubt the majority answer would be something along the lines of thinking for oneself, the desire to learn, the ability to reason etc. Does anyone really believe that it was these qualities that were in over abundance during these crimes against humanity, or was it just more of the same? The demand of blind adherance to doctrine and the subsequent submission without question, like sheep to slaughter.
The Christians during the crusades yelled glory to god as they hacked women and children to death, innocent people were burned alive and tortured if they dared question the authority of the church in any way, Muslims blow themselves up along with dozens of innocent people every day because they believe god will reward them for doing so. Never in history has any act like these been done in the name of atheism, nor will they ever be. The reason is simple because unlike religion or nationalism or communism, atheism is not even an ideology but instead is simply the rejection of one, but even deeper it is a rejection of all ideologies based on blind faith or dogma and it simply implores humanity to instead use our most precious and unique resources reason, rationality and compassion.
[1] Hitler is sometimes included as well, but the history that is available clearly shows that even though he despised Christianity, he also seems to have despised atheists as well and at times he indicated a belief in some kind of god, so he will be left out of the discussion, even though it would have no effect on the arguments to come if he were an atheist.
The Great Plains Observer
3 days ago
